App & extension

Online downloader, browser extension or desktop app: which one should you use?

Online tool, browser extension or desktop app? What each one can see, where its request comes from, and which fits one video, many videos or a channel.

Online downloader, browser extension or desktop app: which one should you use?

In short

Use an online downloader for the odd video, a desktop app for many videos, channels or sites that refuse servers, and a browser extension for a button on the page. The extension is the one that can read your browsing, so check its permissions first. They differ in access, setup and where the request comes from.

Three kinds of tool do the same job: a website you paste a link into, a button added to your browser, and a program on your computer. Most comparisons rank brands. This page compares the three kinds, so you can choose by what you need, and it is plain about the one real trade-off: how much each one can see.

The short answer: pick by how often and how much

Use a website for one video now and then, an app for many videos or whole channels, and an extension when you want a button on the page. Nothing needs installing for the first. The second needs a small install. The third needs a permission check.

Your situationBest choiceWhy
One video, once in a whileOnline websiteNothing to install, works on a phone
Many links, a channel or a playlistDesktop appQueue, folders, retries, no server limits
A site that refuses online serversDesktop appThe request comes from your own connection
You save videos every day while browsingExtension, with the appOne click on the page
A shared or work computerOnline websiteNothing is left installed

Table: Which kind of downloader fits which situation.

The rest of the page explains each row, so you can disagree with it for good reasons.

An online downloader is a web page. You paste a link, the site's server reads the video and offers you a file. It needs no install, no permission and no update, and it works on any phone or computer with a browser.

What it can see is small: the link you paste, and what any website sees (your browser and connection). It cannot read other tabs or other pages you visit.

Its limits come from the same fact. The server, not you, asks the video site for the file. Sites can treat server addresses more strictly than home connections, and shared servers also set limits so one person cannot use everything. Our own measurements of this are in why download websites get blocked more than you do. The other risk is the page itself: ads, fake buttons and pop-ups. We looked at that in are online video downloaders safe.

Two paths: an online downloader asks the video site from a server, while the app asks from your own computer
Caption: who asks the video site for the file, for an online downloader and for the app

Browser extension: the most convenient, the most access

A browser extension adds a button to the pages you watch. It saves a copy and paste, and it can sit right on the video.

It also runs inside your browser, so it is the one of the three that can be given access to pages. Chrome lets you see this. In Chrome's own help, site access has three settings: the extension may act only when you select it, only on a named site, or on all sites (Chrome Help). An extension set to "on all sites" can read and change data on every site you visit. One that works only when you select it can reach only the tab you are on.

Permissions show in Chrome's own words. For example, the downloads permission shows "Manage your downloads", and activeTab shows no warning at all, because it gives temporary access to the current tab only after you click (permissions list). So a short list of narrow permissions is a good sign, and a request for every site is a reason to ask why.

Two more limits to know:

  • A store listing is a review, not a promise that the permissions suit you.
  • An extension often hands the link on to a website or app, so you still depend on that other tool.

Desktop app: more work to set up, fewer limits

A desktop app runs on your computer like any other program. For downloading it has three real advantages.

  1. The request comes from you. The video site sees your home connection, as it does when you watch.
  2. It handles volume. Whole channels, playlists and long lists of links become a queue with a folder per channel. The Raptor app lists a channel first and shows the number of files and the size before you start.
  3. It can wait. When a site says "too many requests", the app waits and tries again after 1, 3 and 6 minutes on its own.

The costs are an install, an update now and then, and trust in the program, so only install apps from the maker's own site. Our guides cover Windows and Mac. An app does not read your browser's pages, which keeps its reach smaller than an extension's.

What each one can see

This is the table most comparisons skip.

Online websiteExtensionDesktop app
Sees the link you give itYesYesYes
Can be allowed to read the pages you visitNoYes, if you grant itNo
Request to the video site comes fromA serverNot itself: it hands the link to the website or the appYour computer
Install and updatesNoneAdd-on, updates through the browser store or by handProgram, updates by hand or in the app
Handles a whole channelLimitedPasses it onYes
Works on a phoneYesMostly noNo

Table: What the three kinds of downloader can see, where their request comes from and what they handle.

The Raptor extension follows the narrow route. On the supported video sites it only places the button and finds the post's link. Its other permissions are the toolbar click, the right-click menu, downloads, settings storage and a connection to the Raptor app on your own computer. The full list, with the reason for each, is in the extension guide. One optional setting, which is off at first, can watch eligible browser downloads from other sites. Read what a setting does before you turn it on. How we handle your data is on the privacy page.

How to choose in two questions

Ask how many videos you save and whether a site refuses you.

  1. One video? Use the website. If it fails, the app is the next step.
  2. Many videos, a channel, or a refusal from the site? Use the app.
  3. Do you want the button on the page? Add the extension, and keep the app running so links go straight to it. Without the app, the Raptor extension opens the website instead.

Our Which one do I need section says the same in three lines.

What none of them changes

The tool does not change what you may download. Save only what you own, what is licensed for it, or what the owner allows, and never use any tool to get around a login, a paywall, copy protection or privacy settings. The rules are in is it legal to download videos. A private video stays private in all three kinds.

Problems you may meet

  • The website says it cannot read a link. The site may refuse servers. Try the app.
  • The extension button does not appear. The page may not be one of the supported sites, or the extension is off for that site in Chrome's site access.
  • The extension does not update by itself. Installed by hand, it is updated by extracting the new ZIP over the old folder, as our install guide describes.
  • An extension you no longer use. Remove it: right-click its icon and choose "Remove from Chrome" (Chrome Help).

Questions people ask

Is a browser extension safer than an online video downloader?

Not by default. An online tool sees only the link you paste. An extension runs inside your browser and, depending on its permissions, can read the pages you visit. A well-made extension with narrow permissions is fine, but it needs a check that a website does not.

Which is best for downloading many videos?

A desktop app. It can list a channel or playlist, keep a queue, retry after a slow-down message and save to a folder on your computer. A website is best for one link at a time, and an extension mainly hands links to something else.

Do I need the app if I use the extension?

With Raptor, no: the extension opens the website when the app is not running. With the app running, the extension sends links straight to it. Other extensions work differently, so read what each one says it does.

Why does an online downloader fail on some sites when an app works?

An online tool asks the video site from a server. Some sites trust server addresses less than home connections and refuse them. An app asks from your own connection, so it is treated like you watching the video.

How do I check what an extension can see?

In Chrome, open Extensions, choose Details and read the site access setting. You can limit it to when you select the extension, to one site, or to all sites. Remove any extension you no longer use.

Are extensions in the Chrome Web Store always safe?

No. A store listing means the extension passed the store's review, not that its permissions suit you. Read what it asks for and why, and keep only the ones you use.

Is the Raptor extension in the Chrome Web Store?

Not yet. Today you add it by hand with Developer mode, which our install guide explains step by step. That is one more reason to read its short permission list first.

Sources

  1. Google Chrome Help: Manage your Chrome extensions (site access and removing)
  2. Chrome for Developers: Permissions list (the warning each permission shows)

First published . Written and checked by the Raptor Downloader team (how we write and check guides). Download only videos you own or have permission to use. Terms · Copyright and takedowns